Helix, Heelix, (H)elix1

Blog EntryBackpacking / portaging tent - Seedhouse 3 SLNov 9, '07 2:56 PM
for everyone

I’m getting older, and my little one is almost to the age where she would go camping in the BWCA with us.  Time to update the somewhat heavy two-man tent I’ve been dragging up North for the last decade.  A ‘three person’ tent that weighs in just less than 4 pounds was perfect... ended up going with a Big Agnes Seedhouse 3 SL.   Interesting concept – a mesh tent with an outer shell.













My bride climbed inside, and quickly reminded me that while there was plenty of room for two people, three was not going to work.  Nuts.  Now I’ll have to pack in two tents – the same old heavy two-man and this three-child ^H^H man, or pick up another tent for me.


























Still, it packed down nice and small… but how does it hold up in the rain and cold?  Heh.  Did a quick Boundary Waters trip this fall.  Far more of a field test than I ever intended. The  night before, we got 11" of rain, so everything, including the ground, was throughly saturated.  Rain continued thought the trip, and the tent kept everything dry.  Not a great shot of the tent in action, but it is what it is when you set up in the dark in a rainstorm.

















The principal disappointment with the tent is the vestibule storage area.  The angle of the tent wall is steep enough that there really was not much usable storage in the gap.  Of the flip side, for one person (or even two), there is plenty of storage area *inside* the tent.  The zippers were water resistant, and could be a little awkward getting into and out of the tent quickly... in the rain.  All of the seams were dry, however.

Glad I set it up at home first.  Poles were in a doubly Y, with one pole over the top.  Nice light poles too.  Liked the tent stakes as well.

I can also see it being tricky to convince people this is a 'solo' one-person tent.  I'm liking all of the room to myself (grin) - lots of very usable space.  Were I to buy again, knowing what I do now... I might go with the two-person version and treat it as a solo tent.  The one-person version looks like a really tight fit.

In dry, warm weather, I'll probably give the mesh tent (without the shell) a try some time.  All the beauty of sleeping under the stars - with mosquito netting.  I have the footprint and could do the 'fast fly' option, but I like a barrier between me and the critters.  Looking forward to the Summer!



iamrevmike wrote on Nov 18, '07
Nice. I've always been a Eureka fan - they make great tents - but I've always been a car camper so the weight has never been a factor.
neim0 wrote on Nov 19, '07
Excellent choice! That said, most "3-person" tents really only fit two. If all three people are okay with spooning, well then it's fine.
tuxette wrote on Nov 19, '07
Yep... if you're two people you should really get a 3-person tent.

Damn... now I want to go camping...
markzero wrote on Nov 19, '07
Did you get much wind during that trip? I'm wondering how an external shell handles that. From the pictures it looks like there may be a gap between the shell and the ground.
heelix wrote on Nov 19, '07
There was a fair bit of wind, but it did not seem noticeable inside the tent. That said - the tent never really 'warmed up' either. Good ventilation - too good to use in the Winter. Not sure if you can tell from the picture, but the bottom of the tent goes up a few inches before it turns into mesh. The top of the tent had about an inch or so vertical overlap, with a two inch gap between the mesh and shell wall. (that make any sense at all?)

Temps were in the 40-50's. My rain gear kept me dry, and the only water in the tent is what I carried in with me. I was worried, as my sleeping bag is down, and that does not mix well with water at all.
pelander wrote on Nov 19, '07
You got a laugh out of me. Good job.
arttolinda wrote on Nov 19, '07
I have a North Face Canyonlands 2 person. Great for just me but 2 people better have a lot in common LOL
schrade wrote on Feb 28
Great product review! Thanks!~ from another outdoorsmen...
Add a Comment
   
© 2008 Multiply, Inc.    About · Blog · Terms · Privacy · Corp Info · Contact Us · Help